Should I Divorce in England and Wales or Hong Kong?
England and Wales and Hong Kong have family law systems with a number of similarities but there are also some important differences for separating couples to be aware of.
In the latest episode of our International Family Law Podcast, David Allison is joined by Caroline McNally of Hugill & Ip, who is qualified in both Hong Kong and England and Wales. Together, they explore how the two jurisdictions approach divorce and separation, and some of the practical considerations for families with connections to both.
Where can you get divorced? Being married in Hong Kong does not automatically mean you can divorce there. Caroline explains the different ways jurisdiction can be established, including domicile, three years’ residence or having a “substantial connection” to Hong Kong. In England and Wales, the rules are based principally on habitual residence and domicile.
Do you need a reason to get divorced? This is one of the key differences. England and Wales now has no-fault divorce, whereas in Hong Kong a spouse may still need to rely on unreasonable behaviour, adultery or a period of separation. David and Caroline discuss what this can mean in practice and how practitioners try to avoid the process creating unnecessary acrimony.
What happens to your finances? There are significant similarities between the two jurisdictions. Hong Kong, like England and Wales, has a discretionary system which considers factors including the parties’ resources, standard of living, contributions and the length of the marriage. The episode also explores matrimonial and non-matrimonial assets, financial needs and the treatment of pre and post-nuptial agreements.
What options are there for staying out of court? Mediation is widely used in Hong Kong, alongside some collaborative law and private financial dispute resolution. David and Caroline compare this with the wider range of options now available in England and Wales, including family arbitration.
What happens when you have children? England and Wales generally follows a “no order” principle, whereas Hong Kong continues to use concepts including custody, care and control and access. The position for unmarried fathers is also different: in Hong Kong, an unmarried father does not automatically acquire parental rights.
What about unmarried couples? In Hong Kong, unmarried partners cannot make the same financial claims against one another as divorcing spouses, although property or trust-based claims may potentially arise. David compares the likeness of this with the position in England and Wales and discusses proposals for reform here.
Every international relationship brings its own circumstances and considerations, particularly when there are connections to more than one country. Understanding the different approaches can help individuals feel better informed about the options available to them.
Watch or listen to the full episode to hear David and Caroline explore the key similarities and differences between family law in England and Wales and Hong Kong.